My ds scored terribly on the erb any suggestions as to what I should do? All I ever hear in that everyone in Manhattan scores in the 90th percentile and above. How can this be true? Is it?

39 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
Click Here
Click Here

Stay Connected with UrbanBaby:

Inside UrbanBaby

UrbanBabyBuzz

snowyv.jpgSnowy Valentine by David Meet Jasper, he’s a little bunny on a mission to surprise his wife for Valentine’s Day. He wants the perfect present, so trudges out in the snow looking for inspiration from his neighbors. When no gif ... More »

UrbanBabyNewYork

The Red Balloon at Poets HouseGoClifftord’s Heart-y PartyCuddle up and listen to the Big Red Dog’s favorite Valentine’s Day books, make holiday cards and take a picture with the lovable pup.When: Sat. 2/11, 3pm; Ages 3+; Free.Where: The Scholastic Store, ... More »
  • My ds scored terribly on the erb any suggestions as to what I should do? All I ever hear in that everyone in Manhattan scores in the 90th percentile and above. How can this be true? Is it?

    39 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    • go public. there's no shame in it...

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.05.09, 05:31 PM Flag
    • People lie. Especially on UB. Your ds will be fine. Just send him to a good public. It worked for most of us.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.05.09, 05:33 PM Flag
    • Give me an O...O!, give me an L...L!, give me an S...S!, give me an A...A!, give me a....

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.05.09, 05:35 PM Flag
      • What does that stand for please excuse my ignorance. I only have one child and I had 5 miscarriages before I was able to have him. I feel as though I failed him.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.05.09, 05:42 PM Flag
        • Attempt to say redirect your energy towards OLSAT, the test for gifted and talented public schools.

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.05.09, 05:53 PM Flag
        • OMG, please don't say that. you didn't fail anyone. he is what he is, and love him regardless of a silly test score. he'll do great in the long run...just wait and see!

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.05.09, 05:56 PM Flag
      • What does O L S A mean?

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.05.09, 05:50 PM Flag
        • I think the lady above is talking OLSAT....for public school tests.

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.05.09, 05:53 PM Flag
    • what does "terribly" mean? what did ds get? Just apply to schools that will be right for that score. PSD will be able to guide you

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.05.09, 05:36 PM Flag
      • np Ditto. People want those top 15 or so schools, though.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.05.09, 05:38 PM Flag
        • Do people prep their kids for the erb?

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.05.09, 05:46 PM Flag
          • of course they do, everyone in Manhattan is neurotic about getting their kids into the "right" schools

            [ Reply | More ]
            11.05.09, 05:54 PM Flag
      • He scored in thee 55th percentile. He is bright. Thank you for your kind words. I spoke with someone and she tried to indicate that there was something wrong with him. He went to a well known Prek for 3 years and now he is in a Montessori school. He has learned mored since September than he learned in the previous 3 years. I moved him because they did not get boys at all.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.05.09, 05:39 PM Flag
        • the honest truth is that a 55th percetnile will not get you into NYC private schools. I might consider staying at your Montessori if he can, if your local public is not an option. Where you applying for 1st grade?

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.05.09, 05:56 PM Flag
          • I am hoping to keep him in the Montessori for Kindergarten then take the erb again and hopefully apply to a boy's school-Browning, St Davids. Do you have any ideas?

            [ Reply | More ]
            11.05.09, 06:02 PM Flag
            • how did he have 3 years before this year?

              [ Reply | More ]
              11.05.09, 06:06 PM Flag
              • A playgroup at the school when he was 18 months to ensure that he would have a spot in the preschool

                [ Reply | More ]
                11.05.09, 06:09 PM Flag
            • honestly, with a 55, I would try and understand why his scores were what they were....perhaps an indicator for something you need to work on (could be shy-ness or focus, not necesarily an "issue"). Schools will see your previous score as well as this one. St. David's can be very competitive.

              [ Reply | More ]
              11.05.09, 06:09 PM Flag
              • Do you think it can be a maturity issue- he was at a new school, in a strange room with a stranger and had only been back at school less than a month?

                [ Reply | More ]
                11.05.09, 06:12 PM Flag
                • sure, ti could be anything! he is a little kid. But you need to read the commentary as well as the scores of individual sections.

                  [ Reply | More ]
                  11.05.09, 06:38 PM Flag
                • np Unless you're a Trump, 55 isn't going to get your kid into those schools. Lots of kids get 99x3 at erb office--strange room, strange place and stranger. Be realistic. Really.

                  [ Reply | More ]
                  11.05.09, 06:45 PM Flag
                  • Please refrain from being so harsh I am quite upset this is my child we are talking about.

                    [ Reply | More ]
                    11.05.09, 07:01 PM Flag
                  • Also I would not want to be related to Donald Trump in any way he and I do not have the same values.

                    [ Reply | More ]
                    11.05.09, 07:04 PM Flag
              • What if I transfer him into a school in 5th or 6th grade do those scores still follow him?

                [ Reply | More ]
                11.05.09, 06:22 PM Flag
                • For some reason, I think they are on your permanant record. But schools will discount them. This is a good quesiton for the ERB office.

                  [ Reply | More ]
                  11.05.09, 06:39 PM Flag
                  • np Doesn't matter--IF the kid has top grades.

                    [ Reply | More ]
                    11.05.09, 06:47 PM Flag
                    • What do you mean? Doesn't mean-If the kid has top grades?

                      [ Reply | More ]
                      11.05.09, 06:59 PM Flag
                • These scores go on his permanent record? How is that possible. He is 4? When we apply to HS they will have these scores?

                  [ Reply | More ]
                  11.05.09, 06:44 PM Flag
      • She has been great!

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.05.09, 05:47 PM Flag
    • he is your darling little boy-the same child before you found out his results.Please don't treat him like there is something wrong with him-children can feel that.And make sure you don't treat him in a way that will change his behavior-self-fulfilling prophecy?(sorry if I make mistakes,English is not my first language).There is a lot of pressure on this children nowadays.I agree with a good public school(move/rent if you have to).Try to find out the areas where he did less well-if speech,see a speech therapist a few times to find out how you can stimulate him etc.You did not fail him, it is just a test and expectations are too big at this age.OLSAT is a free test, you will get some more feed back from those results.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.05.09, 06:40 PM Flag
      • Thanks for your kind words. You are right he is my darling boy and I love him. Warren Buffet was reject from Harvard Business School and Bill Gates and Matt Damon dropped out of Harvard. I have to keep this in perspective.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.05.09, 06:47 PM Flag
        • Matt Damon is quite nice, but not that smart

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.05.09, 07:46 PM Flag
          • Smart enought to get into Harvard. So he can't be that dumb considering he is a white male.

            [ Reply | More ]
            11.06.09, 12:56 PM Flag
        • if you think the scores are not correct and you can afford it, have him privately tested. if you go back and do ERB again, they must report scores. if the private tester does it, you can send them to schools if he does better and, if he does the same, chuck them. these tests are nothing more than an indication. If he's bright, he's bright. It just sucks for you.

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.05.09, 07:53 PM Flag
          • i think that this is good advice. heave him tested privately. if the scores are radically different, you can certainly send them to the schools this year. if they aren't, you will have to sit down and figure out an alternate plan. of course he could transfer into a private school later (these scores will not follow him). but you need to worry about right now. if the montessori has been as good for him as you say, there is no reason not to keep him there for a few years. my friend's son was a very smart boy with a bad erb. they didn't get in anywhere and ended up in westchester where he is thriving. i am not telling you to move out of the city. i am just saying that there are many options other than a nyc private school. you just need to re-focus your efforts now. good luck to you.

            [ Reply | More ]
            11.06.09, 07:51 AM Flag
            • Thank you for your kind words/

              [ Reply | More ]
              11.06.09, 12:56 PM Flag
              • I am glad you read them in the kind tone they were written (ub posts are sometimes hard to interpret because there is no "tone". Seriously, though, I feel for you because I watched my friend go through it and it was very difficult to watch her stress and suffering ( it hurts to have your wonderful child rejected by people who really know very little about him/her). Having said that, I am a big believer in always having a plan b (and c and d if possible). It sounds like you have a few options to consider. And that is a very good thing.

                [ Reply | More ]
                11.06.09, 01:17 PM Flag
    • DS got 50 x 3. I was so new to NYC that I thought that meant he was perfectly on track, which he is. Test score does not shake my faith in him or the environment that his 2 PhD parents provide for him. We only applied to a few privates; rejected at a very tough one, rejected at his sib's school, accepted where we had a strong connection (not sure if they saw ERB score).

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.06.09, 03:19 PM Flag
      • I am glad to hear that. I am sure that your son will grow up to be a wonderful person and it is a testament to how you and your husband raised him. I feel better when people are honest and supportive. I had felt so isolated and cried for 3 days. Thanks again.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.07.09, 01:31 PM Flag
Refresh » New Post »