11.03.09, 06:35 PM 85 replies
Return to talk

Just got a written notice via HR that I need a better attitude or I'll be fired in 60 days. I'm a professional and have nevr had to deal w/ such pettiness. It say absolutely nothing about performance. My new boss is a 40 something w/ no kids and I'm 39 w/ 3 kids I think this is very personal. Is there anything I can do?

85 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
11.03.09, 06:35 PM Flag ]
Click Here
Click Here

Stay Connected with UrbanBaby:

Inside UrbanBaby

UrbanBabyBuzz

snowyv.jpgSnowy Valentine by David Meet Jasper, he’s a little bunny on a mission to surprise his wife for Valentine’s Day. He wants the perfect present, so trudges out in the snow looking for inspiration from his neighbors. When no gif ... More »
  • Just got a written notice via HR that I need a better attitude or I'll be fired in 60 days. I'm a professional and have nevr had to deal w/ such pettiness. It say absolutely nothing about performance. My new boss is a 40 something w/ no kids and I'm 39 w/ 3 kids I think this is very personal. Is there anything I can do?

    85 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    11.03.09, 06:35 PM Flag ]
    • How is your attitude, honestly? And do you want to keep job? Maybe new boss has been told to cut staff, and they are setting you up.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.03.09, 06:37 PM Flag
      • ITA. they are leaving a paper trail so they can fire you. start evacuation procedures--back up computer, files, etc.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.03.09, 06:41 PM Flag
      • Attitude is not so great becuase she has asked me to do things way below my level(because she has fired all of those people). I think she dislikes because I am married and happy and she is not--she get along great with a 45 year old colleage w/ no kids. She is setting me up but what can I do? Company is doing fine--no need to lay off.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.03.09, 06:44 PM Flag
        • OK, first of all, you do sound like you have an attitude. If she evaluates you negatively in a professional setting, it must be because she is jealous? Second of all, the economy sucks, and if she fired a bunch of people, then you need to step up and do the work. As a manager I absolutely hate it when someone argues with me that they won't do an assignment.

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.03.09, 06:47 PM Flag
          • But as a manager don;t you think you shoud discuss first before going to HR? I have had nothing but glowing reports up this point and she has ever said a word in person to me. When I asked her why she hadn't said anythig to me prior to approaching HR she told me she was busy with vacation plans.

            [ Reply | More ]
            11.03.09, 06:53 PM Flag
            • Yes, I do think she should have discussed it with you. Here how I would've handled it. After you refused the assignments, I would have sat down with you and document the conversation. Then if you still refused, I would've sat down with you with a witness. Only after at least that I would've gone to HR. So I think you have legit points and I think you should schedule an appointment with HR to discuss your concerns about how her expectations of you are unclear. HOWEVER, do not bring up her vacation plans or her jealously or the DB issue because all those things make it sound like you do in fact have an attitude.

              [ Reply | More ]
              11.03.09, 06:57 PM Flag
              • I have never refused an assignment in fact I have done them well even though they are with in my job requirements. have I been happy about it.. No but I have done it all and well.

                [ Reply | More ]
                11.03.09, 07:03 PM Flag
                • Yes but you have an attitude about it! I mean, you even have an attitude now, on this board, despite the soundness of the advice that's been given here, so I'm with your boss on this one.

                  [ Reply | More ]
                  11.03.09, 07:05 PM Flag
                • ^^But I do agree with you on your other points. It just seems so petty to go to HR but I guess she has chosen this forum and I will have to pursue it from there.

                  [ Reply | More ]
                  11.03.09, 07:06 PM Flag
        • If you want to keep job, then sit down with her, and discuss it. Say you find it off-putting to be assigned tasks out of your jurisdiction, and whilst you are happy to do as much as you can to help, you cannot do 3 people's jobs. Figure out a solution, such as training new assistant, redesigning work system to eliminate some of the contention etc. Be proactive. You might end up liking this boss, and you might end up with some creative solutions and problem solving that will look good on your resume. Also, have a discreet chat with workplace lawyer, to see if you would have a case. Do not, do not, do it on company computer, it will be monitored.

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.03.09, 06:54 PM Flag
          • Thanks, the thing is I'm pretty high up and completely confounded by this behavior. Lawsuits may get me a bit of money but will kill my career. Time to get a new job.

            [ Reply | More ]
            11.03.09, 07:09 PM Flag
            • Well, you sound pretty sick of this one. Maybe it is time.

              [ Reply | More ]
              11.03.09, 07:20 PM Flag
            • I agree, she is planning to fire you and protecting herself. Act accordingly.

              [ Reply | More ]
              11.04.09, 08:25 AM Flag
    • Perhaps consider reflecting on whether there is any truth to the demand, before rejecting it outright as a personal affront. If it were just that, it's unlikely HR would have pursued it.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.03.09, 06:39 PM Flag
    • did they mention specifics? it might be worthwhile to file a counter-complaint if you feel you are being harrassed.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.03.09, 06:39 PM Flag
    • Sounds like you have an attitude to me.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.03.09, 06:40 PM Flag
    • that's too vague. They must be spelling out this alleged attitude problem and what must happen for it to be "fixed".

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.03.09, 06:41 PM Flag
      • specifically via HR letter -- to have a positive attitude.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.03.09, 06:46 PM Flag
    • How does a boss with no kids mean someone with a vendetta against you?

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.03.09, 06:41 PM Flag
      • Specifics: she stated that I missed a 9am meeting via attitude when she knew that I had been been ER all night long with db. When I called her on it she said it was annoying because it caused he more work the day before her vacation.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.03.09, 06:49 PM Flag
        • np: if you're missing meetings, this is a performance issue! Seriously, you have attitude.

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.03.09, 06:51 PM Flag
        • So you missed a meeting, whether it was for DB or a sick friend it doesn't matter. When you say "via attitude," do you mean how you missed the meeting? It sounds like she didn't care so much that you missed the meeting, but that you missed the meeting and had an attitude about it.

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.03.09, 06:53 PM Flag
          • I didn't have an attitude about missing the meeting I was just quiet since I still smelled of vomit. I didn't want to talk about sick db since it is clearly a point of contention.

            [ Reply | More ]
            11.03.09, 06:57 PM Flag
            • Seriously? Stop thinking this is about your kids. Act like a professional, even if you don't think she is. WHen you start making it personal, you lose credibility.

              [ Reply | More ]
              11.03.09, 06:58 PM Flag
            • np: you sound pretty passive aggressive, like you are a sulker. Not at all professional.

              [ Reply | More ]
              11.03.09, 06:59 PM Flag
              • np..you are a b----. Are you a WOHM?

                [ Reply | More ]
                11.03.09, 07:25 PM Flag
                • hostile much? Why am I a "b---"????

                  [ Reply | More ]
                  11.04.09, 05:34 AM Flag
            • did you or did you not give a reason for missing the meeting? did you apologize?

              [ Reply | More ]
              11.03.09, 07:23 PM Flag
              • OP: I didn't give a reason but I did apologize.

                [ Reply | More ]
                11.03.09, 07:26 PM Flag
                • you made a mistake then.

                  [ Reply | More ]
                  11.03.09, 07:28 PM Flag
                • You just said she knew you were in the ER

                  [ Reply | More ]
                  11.03.09, 07:29 PM Flag
                  • I had the ER papers on my desk since I had to send them to db's doc and she saw them but I did not tell her in the moment

                    [ Reply | More ]
                    11.03.09, 07:32 PM Flag
                    • You cannot assume that. Mb she didn't realize it was your DB, or that it was last night, or she thought DH took DB and that if you were in fact in the ER you would've said something.

                      [ Reply | More ]
                      11.03.09, 07:38 PM Flag
                    • You say she should have been sympathetic to you b/c she knew you were at the ER, yet you didn't tell her you were? You just expected her to piece it together by reading the papers on your desk? That doesn't make any sense. If you expect leeway to take care of family matters, you have to at least provide an explanation.

                      [ Reply | More ]
                      11.04.09, 06:44 AM Flag
                      • ^^although I agree that your boss should have approached you w/ your performance issues and given you a chance to correct them before involving HR.

                        [ Reply | More ]
                        11.04.09, 06:45 AM Flag
                      • ^^^but she should have given you a chance to fix the performance issues on your own before approaching HR.

                        [ Reply | More ]
                        11.04.09, 06:47 AM Flag
                        • ^^oops, double post, sorry.

                          [ Reply | More ]
                          11.04.09, 06:48 AM Flag
            • I am with you. If the work place cannot accommodate you and your family's needs it is time for you to move on. Unfortunately, your boss is an ass and cares more about the bottom line than her employees. Look for a better fit.

              [ Reply | More ]
              11.04.09, 06:05 AM Flag
    • I guess the first thing I would do is ask for some examples of what may have resulted in this letter being sent to you.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.03.09, 06:41 PM Flag
      • it doesn't matter. in ny state you are an at-will employee who can be fired for any reason barring something illegal (age, race or sex discrimination, for example). op's employer is giving her 60 days to find a new job as a courtesy. they plan to fire her.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.03.09, 07:01 PM Flag
        • If you are fired in these circs, can you get unemployment?

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.03.09, 07:03 PM Flag
          • yes

            [ Reply | More ]
            11.03.09, 07:04 PM Flag
          • No

            [ Reply | More ]
            11.03.09, 07:06 PM Flag
            • if the company is being nice enough to give her notice they will say she was downsized. no skin off their backs to let her file for unemployment.

              [ Reply | More ]
              11.03.09, 07:07 PM Flag
              • HR Mom: this is wrong, you can file for unemployment in this case

                [ Reply | More ]
                11.04.09, 06:48 AM Flag
                • depends, actually. you can't collect if you were fired for misconduct. it doesn't seem like that's the case with op but it's unclear.

                  [ Reply | More ]
                  11.04.09, 10:32 AM Flag
          • probably yes, becasue it's not really "cause" - most employers would not with a straight face try to argue to unemployment ALJ that bad "attitude" constitutes "casu".

            [ Reply | More ]
            11.03.09, 07:08 PM Flag
    • If you don't know what it's for then document that with HR. Ask for specific examples. And consider that there may be genuine issue.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.03.09, 07:05 PM Flag
    • Unfortunately, in this country there is nothing you can do. It is basically an oxymoron to say your boss is wrong - your boss may be wrong but you will be fired. Suck it up and get with the program if you want to keep your job.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.03.09, 07:06 PM Flag
      • my dad has a funny sign one of his employees gave him on a shelf in his office. "rules at [name of company]. 1. the boss is always right. 2. if the boss is wrong, refer to rule #1.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.04.09, 05:09 AM Flag
    • why is this personal? because you have kids and he doesn't? maybe you have an attitude problem. sure sounds like it.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.03.09, 07:09 PM Flag
      • It's personal because she never discussed with me went straight to HR.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.03.09, 07:22 PM Flag
        • No, that doesn't mean it was personal. It's a management style.

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.03.09, 07:32 PM Flag
    • Op: I think you are being flamed harshly. She sounds like a bitch and should have had a dialogue with you first. Good luck.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.03.09, 07:15 PM Flag
      • the rest of us are just presenting op with the cold, hard reality. she can be fired for any reason, including her attitude (whatever her company chooses to define this as), and what her boss should have done is a matter of conjecture and not a legal issue.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.03.09, 07:21 PM Flag
        • OP: I understand this but honestly I have never had a boss that I didn't get along with so this is new to me. It's my job to be combative since I negiotiate and I have always been respected.

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.03.09, 07:30 PM Flag
          • believe me, i've been there and it is a tough pill to swallow. of course you are pissed and want to make them see how wrong they are. but the sooner you can accept the fact that you are being fired and move on, the better off you will be.

            [ Reply | More ]
            11.03.09, 07:34 PM Flag
            • I'm in a sort of similar position, and I think OP, you are probably right. Start looking for another job, so sorry.

              [ Reply | More ]
              11.04.09, 04:46 AM Flag
    • Wow! Are any of the respondants here working parents? OP go to HR and fight it bring in the medical records from dc's ER. This sounds like a very nast company.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.03.09, 07:15 PM Flag
      • i'm a working parent who was fired illegally from a very nasty company but chose not to pursue the case. op needs to realize she is about to be terminated and move on, not waste her time on retrieving medical records from the er in an attempt to save her job.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.03.09, 07:26 PM Flag
      • Yes, I am a WOHM and I work in HR.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.03.09, 07:30 PM Flag
    • for her to complain because you missed a meeting due to being up all nite in an ER with your dc shows me clear and simply that she is a vindictive bitch. sorry to say, you may be in a no win situation. you may work FT but your dc are a priority and she wants to put you to a challenge that work takes more priority because she is not a mother and is jealous of the fact that you are, and that you will be there for your dc, no matter what. if it were me, i would leave.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.04.09, 12:00 AM Flag
      • OP did NOT tell her boss she was in the ER. She offered no reason for missing the meeting. Of course boss is pissed.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.04.09, 07:00 AM Flag
      • yes but she never told her boss she was in the ER all night -why in the world wouldn't you tell her? Don't give my that family matters are private. You needed to tell her why you were late to this meeting - not an "oh I'm sorry" What gives - why didn't you tell her?

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.04.09, 07:02 AM Flag
    • All posters: I am extremely skeptical that a high-level employee would receive a warning of that nature from HR after only one incident. OP must have a file from her boss of these types of incidents (whether she deserves to or not). OP, I would say start looking for a job immediately.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.04.09, 03:25 AM Flag
    • You should start looking for a new job, so that you can quit within the next 60 days. You should never work somewhere that treats people in this petty, threatening way.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.04.09, 04:16 AM Flag
    • HR Mom: check the employee handbook for the company's progressive discipline policy. Most companies have a policy of a verbal warning, written warning, probation and can only skip steps for serious issues. Make copies of all performance reviews & emails on your performance. Include good & bad emails so you have the full story if you go lawsuit route. Because NY is an at-will state they can fire you for any reason that isn't illegal with or without warning, your only cause to sue would be to prove that they did not follow the precedent used for other employees AND that there is an illegal reason why they did not follow. It's a tough road to sue here. I'm so sorry but it does sound like they want you out I'd start looking for a new position.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.04.09, 06:56 AM Flag
      • HR Mom, have you heard of the written warning siting "positive attitude" as a remediation? I've always had to lay out specific steps individuals must take to improve performance during the probation period.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.04.09, 07:08 AM Flag
        • I have heard of similar issues especially for a highly placed employee where his/her morale will affect the whole team. for sales and customer service as well where their attitude affects the image the company wants to portray. It's really tough to get out of the hole they dug for OP.

          [ Reply | More ]
          11.04.09, 07:20 AM Flag
          • Yes, once there is written notice its all but impossible to stop. I wouldn't call it "the hole they dug for OP" she is at least partially responsible. She missed a 9AM meeting and offered no excuse. She then expects her boss to read papers on her desk so she would know about an ER visit. This does sound like an attitude problem IMO.

            [ Reply | More ]
            11.04.09, 07:29 AM Flag
            • OP may have an attitude, that's true. I was giving her the benefit of the doubt in order to make the point that even if it was entirely w/o merit it would be very hard for her

              [ Reply | More ]
              11.04.09, 10:01 AM Flag
      • OP: Thanks HR Mom this is the kind of advice I need.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.04.09, 06:02 PM Flag
    • That stinks. I went through something very similar (boss was just one year older than me and a total Bitter Betty about not being married or having kids). Anyway, I was always really nice and polite to her and I documented everything. I wound up quitting which I kind of regret. Don't let her push you out. If you love your job, kill her with kindness and "improve your attitude." GL!

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.04.09, 07:05 AM Flag
    • Do what you need to do to try to keep your job, but get your resume out ASAP - it is much easier to get a new job when you HAVE one. Is it possible to move to a different area in your company - reporting to someone else?

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.04.09, 07:39 AM Flag
    • Your boss does not sound like a great manager but I have a feeling there's WAY more to this than missing one meeting. My sense is that she is, in fact, setting you up to get fired (which I'm not a fan of, I think it's poor management) but I think it's because she sees you as impossible to work with, not because you occasionally have to go to the ER with your kid.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.04.09, 07:46 AM Flag
      • OP didn't tell her boss she was in the ER. She expected her to read papers on her desk and to guess because OP smelled of vomit. All the boss knows is that her employee came to work late and smelling of vomit when she should have been at a 9AM meeting.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.04.09, 07:51 AM Flag
    • From someone who has been in your situation several times: Start packign up and move on. This is a losing battle. It's not worth your mental anguish to fight it. About 2 years ago I had a crazy, CRAZY boss at Lehman who made my life miserable. Finally got smart and got out of there, after therapy and tons of introspection decided it was her not me, but I was still powerless. MUCH MUCH Happier to have left her and her craziness behind, regardless of who was right or wrong.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.04.09, 07:50 AM Flag
      • that you say you've been in this situation "several times" speaks volumes. either most bosses are crazy or it is you. i vote for the latter.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.04.09, 08:03 AM Flag
    • Extensive corporate experience here: Once documentation has started, the ultimate plan is to terminate you. Assume that will happen. Start immediately gathering references other than your boss from your current place of employ and begin new job search. It is easier to be hired elsewhere while you are still employed. Meet w/ boss and talk now.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.04.09, 07:58 AM Flag
      • ...Always better to discuss in person. Be open and honest about all issue including why you missed her meeting. Make a copy of the ER papers and give it to her so she know you are telling the truth. Ask her what you can do to improve and let her know you want to keep your job. Ask for follow up meetings w/ her to discuss progress.

        [ Reply | More ]
        11.04.09, 08:01 AM Flag
    • You are being fired - dust off your resume.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.04.09, 10:18 AM Flag
    • You have a bad attitude. You look down on your boss, you throw a fit about pitching in, and you don't communicate.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.04.09, 10:21 AM Flag
    • forget all of the excuses you are making, but start looking for a new job. In the meantime, ask how you can meet the requirements for the attitude adjustment they want.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.04.09, 10:24 AM Flag
    • Why were you still smelling like vomit when you were at work? Your dc had to go to the emergency room, that's awful. You had already missed a meeting so there was seemingly no need to hurry in. Didn't you shower and change before going to work? Oh, and you should have called/emailed/texted as soon as you could have once you knew you wouldn't make the meeting.

      [ Reply | More ]
      11.04.09, 10:44 AM Flag
Refresh » New Post »