07.02.09, 01:03 PM 95 replies
Return to talk

I've become more pro-choice than ever since having a child; I can't imagine this kind of a responsibility/life change/sacrifice (sometimes) without really really wanting it.

95 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
07.02.09, 01:03 PM Flag ]
Click Here
Click Here

Stay Connected with UrbanBaby:

Inside UrbanBaby

UrbanBabyBuzz

snowyv.jpgSnowy Valentine by David Meet Jasper, he’s a little bunny on a mission to surprise his wife for Valentine’s Day. He wants the perfect present, so trudges out in the snow looking for inspiration from his neighbors. When no gif ... More »

UrbanBabyNewYork

The Red Balloon at Poets HouseGoClifftord’s Heart-y PartyCuddle up and listen to the Big Red Dog’s favorite Valentine’s Day books, make holiday cards and take a picture with the lovable pup.When: Sat. 2/11, 3pm; Ages 3+; Free.Where: The Scholastic Store, ... More »
  • I've become more pro-choice than ever since having a child; I can't imagine this kind of a responsibility/life change/sacrifice (sometimes) without really really wanting it.

    95 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    07.02.09, 01:03 PM Flag ]
    • i was pro choice before, and remain so.

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.02.09, 01:03 PM Flag
      • NP Me too but I am with OP -- more than ever seeing how huge a responsiblity it is from day 1 of pregnancy and forever forward, that people who cannot handle that should be able to choose to terminate

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 04:24 PM Flag
    • hmm I'm about the same as I was, fairly pro-choice, hate that it happens though. It has brought it home to me more though and I find it sad that so many have to go through this route.

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.02.09, 01:10 PM Flag
    • always way, always will be

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.02.09, 01:11 PM Flag
    • me too, even just while I was pregnant.

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.02.09, 01:12 PM Flag
    • I have always been Pro-life. How hard is it to sacrifice nine months of your life and give the baby up for adoption?

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.02.09, 01:31 PM Flag
      • pretty hard in my book

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 01:34 PM Flag
      • I agree. I worry also about the child also who may grow up in the foster care system if they don't have the "desirables" or being abused by the woman who is suppose to care for him or her. Ugh. No easy solutions. Which is why I'm big on promoting birth control. I may be tilting at windmills but so be it.

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 01:38 PM Flag
        • honestly, little babies get adopted right away in this country (even the minorities). Everyone wants babies, it's the kids who are put up for adoption later that have a hard time getting adopted. I'm pro-choice, and am the poster above who said it would be hard in my book, but this isn't a very compelling reason.

          [ Reply | More ]
          07.02.09, 01:40 PM Flag
          • that is not true.

            [ Reply | More ]
            07.02.09, 01:41 PM Flag
          • That is so not true and many, many, many minority babies and toddlers are languishing in foster care in this country.

            [ Reply | More ]
            07.02.09, 01:43 PM Flag
            • You know. Let me just say it. Many, many Black babies.

              [ Reply | More ]
              07.02.09, 01:44 PM Flag
            • of course they are. while people are travelling across the hemisphere to get a child that looks like them. hypocrites.

              [ Reply | More ]
              07.02.09, 01:45 PM Flag
              • ummm, they also travel to Ethiopia to get babies (many who have been taken away from their parents without full disclosure)

                [ Reply | More ]
                07.02.09, 01:47 PM Flag
                • that is a statistically insignificant number of people. stop already.

                  [ Reply | More ]
                  07.02.09, 01:51 PM Flag
                  • I'm not the pro-life loon, I'm pro-choice, but I think that you are wrong. Most babies in this country who get given up immediately after birth get adopted. In my area it is nearly impossible to even become a foster parent for these babies because there is so much competition (assuming no other serious health issues like addiction).

                    [ Reply | More ]
                    07.02.09, 01:54 PM Flag
                    • I don't agree. If you said White babies or Latino babies who look White, maybe some validity.

                      [ Reply | More ]
                      07.02.09, 01:58 PM Flag
                      • I have a friend going through the process, and she is on an extremely long waiting list and is willing to take any baby.

                        [ Reply | More ]
                        07.02.09, 02:00 PM Flag
                        • ^^^but I don't know if this is for the whole country

                          [ Reply | More ]
                          07.02.09, 02:00 PM Flag
                        • statistically, fewer whites have been willing to adopt children of color. hence all those overseas adoptions, which may have peaked.

                          [ Reply | More ]
                          07.02.09, 02:03 PM Flag
                        • but most overseas adoptions are to minority kids, granted mostly asians. People avoid it here because of the risk of the birth mother coming back and changing her mind, not to mention it is fairly recently that mixed race adoptions were allowed

                          [ Reply | More ]
                          07.02.09, 02:09 PM Flag
                        • fairly recently? Mixed race adoptions have been allowed for about 45 years.

                          [ Reply | More ]
                          07.02.09, 02:12 PM Flag
                        • it depends on the state. The Supreme Court had to rule on it in the 90s.

                          [ Reply | More ]
                          07.02.09, 02:13 PM Flag
                        • Actually, that's not entirely true. The resistance actually has come from black caseworkers who believe that black children would be better off in black homes. So this has made it more difficult and this is why so many people have found it "easier" to go overseas. I am black, btw.

                          [ Reply | More ]
                          07.06.09, 08:22 AM Flag
            • That's because their mothers can't care for them, yet haven't released them for adoption!

              [ Reply | More ]
              07.02.09, 02:57 PM Flag
      • that would be anti choice, and it is hard. also, people act as if folks are out there clamoring for babies, but statistics show otherwise.

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 01:40 PM Flag
        • I would love to see your statistic because I'm pretty sure you are wrong

          [ Reply | More ]
          07.02.09, 01:42 PM Flag
          • lol. that's why people go quite to china and korea and turkey - not to adopt children of color, that's for sure.

            [ Reply | More ]
            07.02.09, 01:42 PM Flag
        • Pro choice = for death

          [ Reply | More ]
          07.02.09, 01:44 PM Flag
          • someone get this moron a thesaurus.

            [ Reply | More ]
            07.02.09, 01:45 PM Flag
            • Liberals always come out fighting with the name calling. You are such a classic liberal. Do all liberals go to the same school of indoctrination?

              [ Reply | More ]
              07.02.09, 01:46 PM Flag
              • In a screwy way you are right. If abortion is illegal women will seek to end pregnancies in more and more dangerous ways. Then there will be more death. Yay?

                [ Reply | More ]
                07.02.09, 01:49 PM Flag
                • there has always been abortion. that is what the anti choicers don't understand. i am just advocating safe abortion.

                  [ Reply | More ]
                  07.02.09, 01:52 PM Flag
      • it's not easy to carry that little one around and then just give it up. some people just don't get that.

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 02:53 PM Flag
      • Is this person for real?

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 05:31 PM Flag
      • how hard? Why don't you ask some women who give babies up. Not everyone can do this...I know I wouldn't be able to carry a baby then give it away. WHy be so judgmental with your tone? You should reserve judgment until you are in their shoes

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.03.09, 04:54 AM Flag
    • ITA. it scares the hell out of me that people who don't want babies would be charged with carrying them around for 9 months and perhaps parenting them for the rest of their lives. i definitely give mad props to the women who are willing and able to carry babies for 9 months and give them up for adoption. but i recognize that this is not for everyone, and it is DEFINITELY not in the best interests of a child to have a woman who doesn't want this responsibility determining his/her lifelong health. parenting, and even pregnancy, requires major sacrifice.

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.02.09, 01:40 PM Flag
    • I had two babies 1 at 16 the other at 18. I often think about what I would do if I could relive the moment I had unprotected sex or the moment I found out I was pregnant. I actually thought about putting my baby up for adoption. I confided in a nurse at St. Luke's hospital. You know what she said, a Black baby boy will never get adopted. This was in 1988. To be honest, if I could go back knowing all the struggles, I would have had an abortion. Things worked out alright. I put myself through NYU & Princeton, got remarried to a great guy and have a kid at Cornel and one at American. But there were a few exhausting horrific moments along the way.

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.02.09, 01:53 PM Flag
      • thank you for sharing that. someone is going to flame you, I bet, but you are brave.

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 01:55 PM Flag
        • np-I'm glad you had your babies....and I bet they are glad to be here too.

          [ Reply | More ]
          07.02.09, 01:58 PM Flag
        • i don't see why anybody would flame. you sound like a strong woman and a caring mother. congratulations!

          [ Reply | More ]
          07.02.09, 01:58 PM Flag
        • if anybody flames the above poster i'll come out guns a-blazing.

          [ Reply | More ]
          07.02.09, 02:55 PM Flag
          • I'll be right behind you with my pitchfork. Being a mom at such a young age must've been incredibly hard but it sounds as if you did an amazing job.

            [ Reply | More ]
            07.02.09, 07:22 PM Flag
      • I kinda knew I would get flamed, but I felt like the OP had a good point.

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 02:00 PM Flag
      • Amazing story. I wish it could be shared with the wider world and not just on UB.

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 06:13 PM Flag
    • Ugh. Pro lifer here (as in anti abortion in all but the most desperate medical circumstances, even then, I'm iffy). The fact that you referred to said child as an "it" said it all for me and how you view the lives of the helpless.

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.02.09, 01:57 PM Flag
      • not OP but I think the "it" at the end of the sentence referred to responsibility, not child.

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 01:59 PM Flag
        • Yeah right.

          [ Reply | More ]
          07.02.09, 02:00 PM Flag
          • I think Jenny who can't read is back....

            [ Reply | More ]
            07.02.09, 02:01 PM Flag
            • Nope, sorry, twasn't me, but nice to see your obsession with me is still going strong. ;-)

              [ Reply | More ]
              07.02.09, 10:20 PM Flag
        • i agree. think you misunderstood OR.

          [ Reply | More ]
          07.02.09, 02:01 PM Flag
      • In her sentence, "it" refers back to "responsiblity/life change/sacrifice" (all of which are "its"). I guess you're also anti-good grammar?

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 02:01 PM Flag
        • how surprising.

          [ Reply | More ]
          07.02.09, 02:02 PM Flag
        • No, just anti abortion. Read the post, carefully. You don't WANT life change/responsibility/sacrifice, you WANT a child, or in OP's case, an ". You're the moron.

          [ Reply | More ]
          07.02.09, 02:04 PM Flag
      • Even if she did mean child, that's hardly unusual. Haven't you ever heard anyone say "it's a boy" or "it's a girl"? Do they also lack respect for the "lives of the helpless"?

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 02:13 PM Flag
        • OP here: "it" was meant to be sacrifice, responsibility, etc. But "it" could also refer to the baby without indicating gender, come to think. Anyway...

          [ Reply | More ]
          07.06.09, 07:56 AM Flag
    • Funny. Every time my throat gets heavy when I see that heart beating at the first u/s I feel less and less ok with it.

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.02.09, 02:45 PM Flag
      • You are obviously in the minority. Pro choicers only seem to feel this way when the child is wanted. Otherwise, it's a clump of cells.

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 02:48 PM Flag
        • OR: there is a sub-current feel to your post but I'm not sure what it is...

          [ Reply | More ]
          07.02.09, 03:20 PM Flag
      • np: ITA. I'm pro-choice and will remain pro-choice since it's not MY choice to decide what other women should do with their bodies BUT, I feel the same way. The relief and attachment and protectiveness I felt seeing the HB at 6wks made me less easy to say it's just "a clump of cells". We all need to work together to prevent unwanted pregnancy.

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.06.09, 08:16 AM Flag
    • was pro-choice before, am now after one dd and one on the way. i AM uncomfortable about the fact that i do believe life begins at conception, and after seeing that little heart beat at 8 weeks. but the implications of having a society which forbids abortion are worse. i do wish we had tougher restrictions but that's a different story.

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.02.09, 02:53 PM Flag
    • Odd since I had me dd I have become more pro-life. There are tons of people out there wanting to adopt right now so why not have the babies and let them be adopted instead of killing them.

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.02.09, 03:49 PM Flag
      • The tons of children who grew up and are aging out of foster care would disagree with you on "tons of people wanting to adopt" unless you are only talking about White babies.

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 03:53 PM Flag
      • what about the huge problems that many of the babies have for their entire lives, because the women who carried them didn't want to be pregnant? babies addicted to drugs, babies crippled because of prenatal deficiencies, babies with fetal alcohol syndrome? these babies have a very hard time finding stable homes. even terribly committed and loving foster parents are often unable to handle caring for them for long periods of time.

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 03:56 PM Flag
      • have you actually researched the number of kids available for adoption that cannot be placed? it sounds like you are talking about healthy babies. many of the kids up for adoption are not healthy and have a terrible time being placed. women with unplanned pregnancies are much more likely to give birth to children with serious health problems.

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 03:58 PM Flag
      • according to the latest stats, 130,000 kids in the U.S. foster care system are waiting to be adopted. only 50,000 are adopted per year. most unwanted kids are not adopted. http://www.acf.hhs.gov/programs/cb/stats_research/afcars/trends.htm

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 04:10 PM Flag
    • I've always been pro-choice. It rules! Luv, Jenny ;-) p.s. Pro-lifer whack-jobs are nutty as a fruit-cake. They talk about saving babies but then shoot Doctors! ICK!

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.02.09, 04:00 PM Flagged
    • If men got pregnant, abortion rights would be in the constitution, PERIOD.

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.02.09, 05:29 PM Flag
      • So true!

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 05:40 PM Flag
      • Right, only women are supposed to involuntarily or unwillingly put their lives at risk (people still die of complications of childbirth and labor), vomit unremittingly for 3 months, get heartburn, get fat, be split in two during labor, yadda, yadda... If men got pregnant, Big Pharma would make a pill to stop this horrible disease! Oh right, THEY ALREADY HAVE ONE BUT THE FREAKING PRO-LIFERS MAKE ACCESSING IT A HUGE FREAKING PROBLEM!!!!!!!

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 05:47 PM Flag
        • And, they make sure that Viagra is offered everywhere.

          [ Reply | More ]
          07.02.09, 05:49 PM Flag
          • Sex IS a sin but if you are going to sin you might as well enjoy it while it lasts and then walk away while some woman suffers the consequences for ETERNITY.

            [ Reply | More ]
            07.02.09, 05:54 PM Flag
          • and covered by insurance

            [ Reply | More ]
            07.06.09, 08:34 AM Flag
    • Funny, since I had dd I have become more uncomfortable with the idea of abortion - but I cannot imagine roe v wade going away - it's every woman's choice

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.02.09, 05:34 PM Flag
    • After two dcs (and an abortion 15 yrs ago) I feel more and more that abortion is something I could not do at this stage of my life. But I still think any woman who wants an abortion should be able to have one.

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.02.09, 06:01 PM Flag
    • i'm the opposite.

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.02.09, 07:25 PM Flag
    • I was vehemently pro-choice, former member of NOW and even marched in Washington, but after having my children I became much more pro-life. I still think it's a woman's right to choose but I wish that abortion would be limited to the first trimester, except in very limited circumstances. A woman in my mommy group just had an abortion at 18 weeks because she couldn't make up her mind. Things like this need to be stopped. Flame away if you must, but most of us knew the sex of our babies by that time and here she is thinking should she or shouldn't she? Makes me very sad.

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.02.09, 07:55 PM Flag
      • I'm vehemently pro-choice AND I'm sad, conflicted, and disgusted. When I would speak to teenage girls who were knocked up and were in total denial or just plane wishy-washy, I would want to shake them and want to scream out there are 62 forms of birth control you can get for FREE, YOU IDIOT. Ugh. They just don't understand that it's better to make the decision early. But most are ashamed and really think "it will just go away". Ugh.

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 08:04 PM Flag
        • where do you get bc for free? Not flaming at all--I really do wish people in this country were more frank with themselves and with their teen kids about bc, pregnancy, etc. We have an insane number of unwanted pregnancies in this country. I am another reluctant and conflicted pro-choicer--just wish pro-lifers were more pro-active about tackling the problem at the source, i.e. before it happens.

          [ Reply | More ]
          07.02.09, 08:08 PM Flag
          • I New York City lots of places mostly ran by the government. The Ryan Center is a great place for sexually active teens to go for protection. But in a smaller town probably not many places. The biggest problem use to be, you got knocked up or you got some girl knocked up, but now with HIV and certain drug resistant STDs , I really want teens to make smarter choices but man is it an uphill battle.

            [ Reply | More ]
            07.02.09, 09:22 PM Flag
          • my sister used to get birth control for free from planned parenthood. they have a sliding scale that starts at free.

            [ Reply | More ]
            07.02.09, 10:37 PM Flag
      • Me three... pro-choice, but much sadder about abortion now that I have children. I can't imagine going around 8 months pregnant, carrying a child I wouldn't or couldn't take care of, especially if it were not the child of a man who would make a good father. On the other hand, the sound of that tiny heartbeat is so beloved and precious. It just firms up my conviction that sex education, birth control, childcare education for young parents, and support for pregnant mothers and infants have to be ubiquitous and free. Also that there should be more access to affordable, quality early childcare so that there is no economic reason to terminate a pregnancy.

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 08:53 PM Flag
    • More pro-choice now for a different reason. Ultrasound for my second showed a problem. By the time I went for the more detailed ultrasound it was so late I would have to travel to another city and go to a special doctor to abort if the ultrasound confirmed what we feared, that the baby wouldn't survive after delivery. Thank goodness everything was ok - but I was facing the possibility of the choice of carrying a baby I knew was going to die, when it was also a risky pregnancy for me so my first daughter could end up losing her mom, or ending up with a late term abortion, with all the stigma attached and the fear of attack by pro-lifers. It was horrible to contemplate. I am more strongly in the camp that people should leave moms alone to make their own decisions.

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.02.09, 10:41 PM Flag
      • thank you for sharing your story. i don't think a lot of people consider cases like yours when they are making up their minds about where they stand in this debate. i am so happy that your child was OK!

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.02.09, 10:47 PM Flag
        • Thanks! We are so happy she is ok, my concerns about our kids school choices, weaning, sleeping through the night, thumb-sucking, and whether or not I stay at home all are just not stress-causing. Our kids are alive, healthy, happy, and nice people. Every day since she turned about a year old and we were sure she was going to be as ok as any other kid I have been joyful.

          [ Reply | More ]
          07.02.09, 11:31 PM Flag
          • Heartwarming story; so glad that your little girl is OK!

            [ Reply | More ]
            07.02.09, 11:42 PM Flag
      • np: that's true... the two cases of abortion that I personally know of were both in women who had been struggling with infertility for years and were desperate for a child. In one, the embryo got stuck at the 6 or 8 week point of development but would not progress or die, so at 10 or 12 weeks she couldn't take it any more and had it terminated

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.03.09, 09:52 AM Flag
    • since becoming pregnant i have felt more sympathy for women who give their children up for adoption. DH and i knew we would adopt a child and still plan to - including an older child. i feel a kinship with the mother who carried them and want to help care for her children.

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.03.09, 05:56 AM Flag
    • This is a private decision and should remain private.

      [ Reply | More ]
      07.06.09, 08:36 AM Flag
      • Private? Until you're hearing about a baby being neglected/abused because someone didn't really want it or care about it. Then it's no longer "private".

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.06.09, 08:51 AM Flag
      • is it still private if someone else's tax dollars are paying for it?

        [ Reply | More ]
        07.06.09, 08:52 AM Flag
Refresh » New Post »