Now that it's over, at least almost, who was and continues to be the best DoA?

73 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
Click Here

Stay Connected with UrbanBaby:

Inside UrbanBaby

UrbanBabyBuzz

snowyv.jpgSnowy Valentine by David Meet Jasper, he’s a little bunny on a mission to surprise his wife for Valentine’s Day. He wants the perfect present, so trudges out in the snow looking for inspiration from his neighbors. When no gif ... More »

UrbanBabyNewYork

The Red Balloon at Poets HouseGoClifftord’s Heart-y PartyCuddle up and listen to the Big Red Dog’s favorite Valentine’s Day books, make holiday cards and take a picture with the lovable pup.When: Sat. 2/11, 3pm; Ages 3+; Free.Where: The Scholastic Store, ... More »
  • Now that it's over, at least almost, who was and continues to be the best DoA?

    73 replies [ Reply | Watch | More
    • Babby. Even though we were WL'ed she was honest about our chances to get off the WL.

      [ Reply | More ]
      02.22.09, 09:55 AM Flag
      • She is a great interviewer and advocate for the school. She really does know/get the children she admits. The personalized acceptance letter is a great touch. Very skilled and professional.

        [ Reply | More ]
        02.22.09, 10:43 AM Flag
        • I just loved her rejection letter. She really got my dc.

          [ Reply | More ]
          02.22.09, 11:40 AM Flag
          • Huh? It was a hard year too many qualified applicants for too many spots. . . .

            [ Reply | More ]
            02.22.09, 01:09 PM Flag
        • ITA. And she has really transformed Dalton. working with other visionary staff to enroll a diverse student body and forge an inclusionary community. Babby rocks.

          [ Reply | More ]
          02.22.09, 04:19 PM Flag
        • I got a personalized acceptance letter from Grace. Is that unusual?

          [ Reply | More ]
          02.22.09, 04:39 PM Flag
      • Loved her. Didn't even go to Dalton. But the best advocate the school can have.

        [ Reply | More ]
        02.22.09, 02:38 PM Flag
        • See ITDA and I think Dalton is a great school, while I think she has done some good things - she can be very rude and dismissive and phony seeming - though I don't think she is really like that.

          [ Reply | More ]
          02.22.09, 07:11 PM Flag
          • ITA, and I felt like she was on auto-pilot when she did the tour last Spring - it's clear she is passionate about the school, but it seemed as if she was a robot spewing the Dalton-speak when we toured. I did love the school though - not right for my dc and family, and they thought the same, but an impressive place, nonetheless.

            [ Reply | More ]
            02.28.09, 04:18 PM Flag
    • Martha Hershman at Hewitt (upper grades). What an easy transition she made for us.

      [ Reply | More ]
      02.22.09, 09:59 AM Flag
      • NP; you cannot nominate your doa if you got into that school. conflict of interest.

        [ Reply | More ]
        02.22.09, 10:05 AM Flag
    • In the long run, who cares about the DoA? Shouldn't we be discussing the "best" principal, head of school, head of lower school?

      [ Reply | More ]
      02.22.09, 10:07 AM Flag
      • np: Yes, the long run. But most of us only met the HOS is passing. All we know for sure is how the DoA performs. I hate people who have to take issue with every post as written.

        [ Reply | More ]
        02.22.09, 10:08 AM Flag
        • Why can't I voice my opinion about the original post?

          [ Reply | More ]
          02.22.09, 10:10 AM Flag
          • obviously you can. The point is that some people need to take the devils advocate position of every freaking post just to make themselves feel superior for thinking out of the box or whatever. It's just annoying & it's obvious you have nothing to contribute to the actual post other than the opposite viewpoint.

            [ Reply | More ]
            02.22.09, 10:11 AM Flag
            • Are you new to UB?

              [ Reply | More ]
              02.22.09, 10:13 AM Flag
              • not at all. that doesn't make it less annoying. I hate those people irl too, btw.

                [ Reply | More ]
                02.22.09, 10:14 AM Flag
                • You're just full of judgment and hatred, aren't you?

                  [ Reply | More ]
                  02.22.09, 10:15 AM Flag
                  • um, no. You would be the one who can't let someone have a thought without judging it and taking the opposite position. Omg, you're dense.

                    [ Reply | More ]
                    02.22.09, 10:17 AM Flag
                    • I'm not judging the original post and I'm not taking an opposite position at all. I'm having a conversation. If you read the posts as an actual conversation, what I wrote is just another voice joining in. In real life, what you wrote would be very rude if voiced out loud to a person.

                      [ Reply | More ]
                      02.22.09, 10:21 AM Flag
                      • Of course it would be rude irl. So is arguing for argument's sake imo. Even irl, there are people who will stand there and when you take any position whatsoever they will argue it even if it is different every time. Think about it... are you this type? If so, some people (me inc.) find it annoying. I don't expect you to agree as that would not fit your M.O.

                        [ Reply | More ]
                        02.22.09, 10:27 AM Flag
                        • You win. You always win, don't you?

                          [ Reply | More ]
                          02.22.09, 10:41 AM Flag
                        • only when I'm right.

                          [ Reply | More ]
                          02.22.09, 10:44 AM Flag
                        • Are you two my two sisters???

                          [ Reply | More ]
                          02.22.09, 01:05 PM Flag
        • np But the DOA doesn't matter at all once you're in. To be honest, we didn't interview with DOA at our fc tt and our dc's been at the school for a few years. Wouldn't know DOA if I saw her in the street.

          [ Reply | More ]
          02.22.09, 10:13 AM Flag
          • again, we haven't even sent in our contract. You are missing the point. The point of the original post asks who is the best DOA. I don't care if I never see any of them again, but I do have an opinion on the doas right now even more so than I do HOSs who I've never met.

            [ Reply | More ]
            02.22.09, 10:16 AM Flag
            • OP: Can we get back to the original post/question PLEASE?

              [ Reply | More ]
              02.22.09, 10:30 AM Flag
              • But why bother because the doa's are insignificant apparently. Your post was a waste of space.

                [ Reply | More ]
                02.22.09, 10:37 AM Flag
                • some continue to have influence in the first couple years.

                  [ Reply | More ]
                  02.22.09, 10:41 AM Flag
              • the woman at ST H/St H was nice.

                [ Reply | More ]
                02.22.09, 10:37 AM Flag
                • ITA! both of them

                  [ Reply | More ]
                  02.22.09, 10:38 AM Flag
                • loved both kate and esther. great, warm, authentic.

                  [ Reply | More ]
                  02.22.09, 07:08 PM Flag
      • this is what we would be doing if we chose the schools, i think. i agree it's a more important question. best head of school: calhoun, head of lower school: fieldston.

        [ Reply | More ]
        02.22.09, 10:41 AM Flag
        • worst is grace and best is spence

          [ Reply | More ]
          02.22.09, 10:59 AM Flag
    • Simone

      [ Reply | More ]
      02.22.09, 10:37 AM Flag
      • really? i found her strident to the point of arrogance. or maybe it was just the demand for a FC letter that rubbed me the wrong way.

        [ Reply | More ]
        02.22.09, 10:41 AM Flag
        • i thought she was forthright and honest. i appreciated her bluntness.

          [ Reply | More ]
          02.22.09, 10:42 AM Flag
          • two sides of the same coin i guess

            [ Reply | More ]
            02.22.09, 10:42 AM Flag
      • omg, I hated her above all others. She seemed smug. Almost pulled my app there b/c of her until I realized that I'd never have to see her again if dc did go there (not).

        [ Reply | More ]
        02.22.09, 10:53 AM Flag
        • ita. i did like the head of school though, the elderly gentleman

          [ Reply | More ]
          02.22.09, 10:55 AM Flag
    • i liked the second in command at spence and really like the hos.

      [ Reply | More ]
      02.22.09, 10:43 AM Flag
      • Who's the second in command at Spence?

        [ Reply | More ]
        02.22.09, 10:45 AM Flag
      • ita. I thought Kathy at Spence was really genuine and normal. Actually pleasant talking to her.

        [ Reply | More ]
        02.22.09, 11:22 AM Flag
        • Actually I think Jessica Christian in second-in-command at Spence. She is very lovely and considerate.

          [ Reply | More ]
          02.23.09, 07:19 AM Flag
    • marcia at bank street. very nice person, gracious, and great feedback on what dc did at playgroup. how many schools are willing to give you that info?

      [ Reply | More ]
      02.22.09, 10:45 AM Flag
      • i liked her too. a lot.

        [ Reply | More ]
        02.22.09, 10:56 AM Flag
        • Ditto here on Marcia. One of her second in commands, Kathleen, was also great. Entire process at Bank Street is very engaging and respectful of prospective parents.

          [ Reply | More ]
          02.25.09, 12:32 PM Flag
          • oh please they are nice but they are also infamous for wait listing MANY just to continue to be "nice"

            [ Reply | More ]
            02.25.09, 06:02 PM Flag
            • Hmm, you seem to have an issue with their being "nice". Would you prefer that they be "rude"? There's just no pleasing some people I guess.

              [ Reply | More ]
              02.25.09, 06:15 PM Flag
              • no just wish the schools would be honest instead of coming up with BS to tell families and WL so many kids they will never be able to accommodate, talk to early steps & Parents league they will tell you BS wl is nice wl

                [ Reply | More ]
                02.25.09, 07:16 PM Flag
                • You know, after reading your post a second time, I have to say that IF you're right about Bank Street giving false hope to lots of people, then YES that does indeed suck. Funny, now that I think of it, our tc school DoA was straight up during the parent interview and said that she thought our family was a good fit with the school but that she had more siblings and legacies than she knew what to do with. Then BOOM, we got accepted. Totally didn't see that coming, but of course it was a great surprise.

                  [ Reply | More ]
                  02.26.09, 05:20 AM Flag
                  • NP: wls are a dime a dozen. usually reject, unless it's a priority or the doa tells you otherwise

                    [ Reply | More ]
                    02.26.09, 05:51 AM Flag
          • Hmmm...Yes on Marcia but I really feel it's pretty manufactured 'nice' on the Kathleen end.

            [ Reply | More ]
            02.25.09, 07:55 PM Flag
    • 1st prize...Barbara Root. Can someone please give me an HONEST answer on why she's leaving?

      [ Reply | More ]
      02.22.09, 11:14 AM Flag
      • Is she really leaving? Maybe retiring?

        [ Reply | More ]
        02.22.09, 12:14 PM Flag
      • She's been there for years, hasn't she? And she's got to be in her early to mid 60s, don't you think? ITA she was the nicest DOA we encountered when we applied out.

        [ Reply | More ]
        02.22.09, 01:07 PM Flag
      • A lot of people are leaving CSH - there is a new administration and many aren't happy - feel that he is going in too religious of a direction that will alienate more secular NY catholics - don't know if that is why she is leaving though.

        [ Reply | More ]
        02.22.09, 01:09 PM Flag
        • You have no idea what you are talking about. Barbara Root retired. The "he" you refer to, Dr. Ciancaglini, is an excellent head of school. What do you mean too religious? Are you forgetting that CSH is Catholic school, as well as private? Maybe you think it should go in the direction of MM -- Catholic in name only.

          [ Reply | More ]
          02.28.09, 03:15 PM Flag
    • the woman at town. unfortunately i did not like the school.

      [ Reply | More ]
      02.22.09, 11:37 AM Flag
    • Julie Sykes at St David's and Anne Nordeman at St Bernard's. Both class acts who are wonderful ambassadors for their schools. Both were straightforward and honest about the process and enthusiastic and passionate about their schools while also being down to earth. Even the much-maligned Joanne Heyman at Collegiate was a straight shooter and told it like it is. (despite what people say she returned every call) They all understand the madness and psychosis of the process and were refreshing in their approach.

      [ Reply | More ]
      02.22.09, 02:38 PM Flag
      • Agree with that. We loved the St. Davids' team and Anne Nordeman. I also have a lot of respect and liked Joanne Heyman, even though she rejected DS - which was the right call - Collegiate would not have been the place for him (not because of academics, for other reasons). I ended up disliking Babby because "the Dalton show" was just too much show in the end.

        [ Reply | More ]
        02.22.09, 05:07 PM Flag
    • In Brooklyn: Pam of Berkeley Carroll. Just lovely!

      [ Reply | More ]
      02.22.09, 03:50 PM Flag
    • I liked Diana at St Ann. I'm sure I'll get flamed, but sorry, I liked her.

      [ Reply | More ]
      02.22.09, 05:03 PM Flag
    • Sarah Lafferty--Riverdale

      [ Reply | More ]
      02.22.09, 05:17 PM Flag
    • Valorie Iason at Packer, although we got waitlisted.

      [ Reply | More ]
      02.22.09, 06:08 PM Flag
      • And we really liked Jason Caldwell (for the MS/HS there). And Yvonne and Kati are great too.

        [ Reply | More ]
        02.25.09, 03:35 PM Flag
        • Jason Caldwell - Packer MS/HS. He's outstanding!

          [ Reply | More ]
          02.25.09, 07:17 PM Flag
    • Lillian Issa at Marymount. Honest, kind and passionate about her school.

      [ Reply | More ]
      02.25.09, 06:17 PM Flag
    • I liked Joanne Heyman only because she's a no bull shit woman who asks real interview questions. If you really "get" Collegiate she'll love you, if you don't she won't. She's also not blinded by celebrity or beholden to $$ like babby and many of the others.

      [ Reply | More ]
      02.28.09, 03:37 PM Flag
Refresh » New Post »