new post »
see more posts »
My 3yo daughter will not talk to other children -- not at school, not at camp, not on playdates. She is 3.4 months. Is this normal? She is very verbal with people she knows, and responds to other adults one on one, but is silent and shy with other children. Sometimes it seems like all the other kids her age are already talking to each other.
25 replies [ Reply | Watch | Options ]OP: She has been around other dc on a daily basis, yes. But she is not talking to other kids even so.
[ Reply | Options ]Do you talk to other dc - her friends - do you sit and talk and play with the other dc - lead your dd into conversations with them
[ Reply | Options ]np: my 3yo is pretty quiet with otherr kids too, except her sibling and kids she has known a long time. a lot of kids in one setting makes her clam up. i don't think its abnormal, but i'd try to see one or two otehr kids regualrly, evne if you jut meet up at the park. then seh may get comfortable wnough to talk.
[ Reply | Options ]OP: Unfortunately, we do not live in an area with young children, so it's hard to meet up one on one with other kids on a regular basis. The problem isn't that she's pretty quiet, it's that she literally does not say a single word. Not even yes or now when asked a question.
[ Reply | Options ]Have you asked her why? 3.5 she should be able to communicate her feelings to you. I hope you won't take this the wrong way but one thing I've noticed with friends of mine that kids have nanny's is they don't always have the best language skills. Is you Nanny talking to her a lot? Is English her first language?
[ Reply | Options ]
she is sort of past the stage of parallel play-have you spoken to her teachers about this? is she an only dc? my younger dc is pretty shy/quiet around other kids her own age, but she is very verbal with her older sib's friends. i am not worried about it at this point. just figure dd is trying to make sense of things. if you are worried, talk to teacher. also, try to do stuff one on one with other kids if you can-may seem less overwhelming. witha structure activity too, so they don't have to necessarily take the initiative (like, come on guys, we are going to do a puzzle together. do you like to do them? do you like the colors on this puzzle, oh wow, sally, did you hear that katie loves yellow too?)
[ Reply | Options ]OP: Well, right now she is at camp, which just started, so I haven't talked to camp counselor yet. The problem isn't that she's quiet -- it's that she literally will not say a single word, not even yes or no in response to a question. She just looks down or turns away if another child talks to her. If I try to coordinate the conversation, she'll just look at me and respond, but will not talk to the other child.
[ Reply | Options ]the counselors may not be helpful-some are great, some aren't as much. does she seem unhappy to you? if she is happy, no big deal, but if not, that might worry me and might be worth starting to explore. I wouldn't do much this summer, wait until return to school too, when teachers (who are usually better trained than counselors) may have more info for you. also, try to observe when this happens-is it playdates or in group settings? my older dc hated to be the last one in preschool in the morning-wanted to be first and get settled. just wasn't a big transition kid-once we figured this out, dc came out of shell more
[ Reply | Options ]
OP: Do a lot of other children not talk to other kids at 3.4? When do most kids start talking to other children?
[ Reply | Options ]My DS was really, really quiet--sometimes not talking--in certain social situations at that age. He literally barely spoke during his entire time at preschool. They recommended against sending him to kinder--we didn't listen and he had a great year. One thing that seemed to be a turning point for him was going to a very low-key camp last summer w/ lots of time out in nature (he's very comfortable in nature) where he made one really good friend (also a socially awkward late-blooming boy). He's back there this summer and doing totally fine and now he'll go to a park and join the play, talk to other kids or adults. Hope that helps.
[ Reply | Options ]
-
my dd is like this too. she's almost painfully shy when she's in a new setting, away from her comfort zone. i made playdates with 1 or 2 other kids so that when she's in a larger group setting, she has a few familiar faces. that has seemed to help. fwiw, she's been in classes or playgroups since she was 6 mo, so its not a lack of socialization. its just her. will she speak to them when she's one on one with them?
[ Reply | Options ]A Speech Pathologist will help facilitate communication between your child and her peers. I recommend www.liftprogram.com - she's wonderful and has social language play groups to help kids communicate during play. Good luck!
[ Reply | Options ]
Boards Help
Abbreviations
More Boards Help
Site Feedback Thank you for your feedback about the new site. We are paying close attention to your comments and we will incorporate them as we make improvements to the site. Please continue to report problems and offer feedback on the Site Feedback Board and visit our Site Talk blog for answers to some of your questions and updates on specific issues.
More Boards Help
Site Feedback Thank you for your feedback about the new site. We are paying close attention to your comments and we will incorporate them as we make improvements to the site. Please continue to report problems and offer feedback on the Site Feedback Board and visit our Site Talk blog for answers to some of your questions and updates on specific issues.
Flashback
